Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Jane McGonigal. Did she make a good argument?



In Dr. Jane McGonigal’s video “Gaming Can Make a Better World” she makes the argument about how people can change the world by playing video games. She makes a couple valid points to back up her thoughts. One of her first arguments is saying that the only way we’re going to survive the next century on this planet is to increase the amount of game play from 3 billion hours to 21 billion hours. In doing this she believes we will help solve problems such as hunger, poverty, climate change, global conflict, and obesity. She believes if we can get people to save the real world like they do in game world then we could really make a difference. She shows a picture taken by Phil Tildano of a boy whose face shows some fear, excitement, anxiousness, and deep concentration. McGonigal calls this the face of an epic win. Stating that an epic win is an outcome in which they had no idea was possible until they achieve it. She wants to see this face on problem solvers around the world while trying to solve world problems. But unfortunately the face we make as problem solvers is the “I’m not good at life face” basically lowering our self-confidence and motivation to solve problems. One of my favorite arguments is about how ancient historian Herodotus wrote about a kingdom in Lidia and how they invented ancient dice made from sheep knuckles and that is where the first dice games were invented and played. The kingdom of Lidia was in such a horrible famine so the king set up a policy that one-day they would eat and then the next day they would play games - in order to get their minds off of the fact that they had no food. McGonigal believes that this is how we use games today too. She feels that we play games to escape real world suffering and everything not satisfying about real life. I cannot say I fully agree with Jane McGonigal because I do not personally play enough video games to know if we could change the world, but I can say that she has some very convincing arguments. I believe that if she really got out there and tested the games she made and spoke more on her thoughts she could really make a huge difference. Who knows, maybe she’s got the right idea and we all need to open our minds and see what could come out of it.





2 comments:

  1. I like how you talked about the ancient kingdom in Lydia. It's a very interesting story and relates to this topic so well. I agree with you when you say we all need to open our minds, but I don't think that will ever happen. No one has the mindset to bring in such a huge idea and try to work together to make it change the world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks, I thought it was a good point to be added in. I can understand where you're coming from not thinking that this will help change the world. But I do believe you should take into count Jane McGonigal's personal video games she created. I think if you played them you'd see how they could help because they are geared towards real life issues. On the flip side I can say that as of right now its hard to believe anything like that can change the world because we aren't seeing proof, but just wait maybe someday they will actually further her studies in changing the world through gaming and it could possibly help us.

    ReplyDelete